Follow The Propagandist on Twitter

Subscribe to us! The Propagandist On Facebook Follow The Propagandist On Twitter Subscribe the The Propagandist by Email Get The Propagandist Newsletter

Donate to The Propagandist

Bibi Aisha

South African photographer Jodi Bieber has won the World Press Photo of the Year for her photo of Bibi Aisha, the 18-year-old Afghan woman who was mutilated by her husband by order of the Taliban. Aisha's photo appeared on the cover of Time Magazine in August 2010, igniting controversy.

Many felt that the photo courageously confronted who the Taliban really are and what the consequences of another western abandonment of Afghanistan may look like, with its headline, "What Happens If We Leave Afghanistan". The same headline infuriated stoppists, who accused the magazine of "emotional blackmail," and coined rather ridiculous terms such as "mutilation chic".

The portrait is unique in that it communicates the story of Bibi Aisha's horrific experience with great dignity; she appears as a survivor, rather than a helpless victim. Bieber managed to capture an expression of pride, resolve and a grave stare that implored viewers to acknowledgeme the crime that Aisha had endured, and not to turn away. As Terry Glavin pointed out,

Lost in all the self-serving and cowardly Code Pinkish yesbuttery and

...More >>

afhganistan bibi ayesha women rightsBy way of an update, I never did receive a response from Ann Jones to the questions in my open letter to her last month. That's when I sought some clarifications around Jones' dismissal of the Time magazine cover of 18-year-old Bibi Aisha, who had been mutilated by Taliban order. Jones had suggested Aisha was lying because she was "traumatized". She claimed she knew Ayesha, and criticized those who "demonize" the Taliban.

However, today I received some answers from Women for Afghan Women, the US and Afghanistan-based organization which housed and cared for Aisha for nine months, and arranged for her medical treatment in the United States. Esther Hyneman, a board member and full-time volunteer with WAW, writes in the Huffington Post:

Ann Jones' claim in the Nation that she "know[s]" Bibi Ayesha (after conducting a single interview with her) is a somewhat disingenuous attempt to cast doubt on the veracity of statements by Time magazine and Women for Afghan Women (WAW) that Taliban were responsible for the monstrous crime perpetrated against this young woman.

Hyneman was also critical...More >>

This morning at 9:00am in Kabul, 46 girls and their teachers were poisoned in their classroom at the

Tuteya Girls' Primary School in the Karte Naw neighbourhood of Kabul. The girls have been hospitalized, and it appears that a chemical gas was sprayed in their class some time before their arrival. While the incident is still being investigated, this is a trademark tactic of the Taliban's, who remain fundamentally opposed to the education of girls and women. One might say they are simply opposed to girls and women, period. This evidently doesn't bother a lot of people in the West, as in James Fergusson's recent nod to Taliban misogyny.

But it really bothers me. Because for all the cultural relativism trumpeted in the west, Afghan girls still show up to school when their classmates end up poisoned in the hospital, their teachers end up dead, their principals beheaded, and their schools burned down. They want to go to school that badly. A 17-year-old student at the Mirwais Mena Girls School in Kandahar, Shamsia, suffered severe eye injuries in 2008 when Taliban threw acid on her and her classmates on their way to morning classes. Days after the attack,...More >>

Loading...

BUY @ the eSTORE

propagandist tshirt political merchandise buy magazine

Sponsor The Propagandist

Buy The Detective vs. the Slime Monster from Outer Space

political documentaries

Join The Propagandist

Buy A History of The Middle Eastside