Follow The Propagandist on Twitter

Subscribe to us! The Propagandist On Facebook Follow The Propagandist On Twitter Subscribe the The Propagandist by Email Get The Propagandist Newsletter

Donate to The Propagandist

Z Word


Over at Normblog and under the title ‘A Cool Hour on the Israel-Palestine Conflict', Samuel Fleischacker begins what promises to be an extremely interesting series of posts here. Although I share his overall view that what is involved in this conflict is a "tragic clash of just claims", I'd like to take issue here with some of the points he makes.

Fleischacker says,

Moreover, almost all Arabs and Muslims believe that the establishment of a Jewish state

...More >>

Here's Terry Glavin, who proudly notes that the convention which denounced the boycott campaign against Israel took place in his home town of Victoria. Terry includes a photo of Jamaican-born Ucal Powell - President of the Carpenters' District Council of Ontario and the man who slammed the boycott in no uncertain terms - hard at work in post-Katrina New Orleans. Ucal provided his services free of charge because the devastation in New Orleans reminded him of the hurricane which devastated Jamaica when he was a kid. Now there, as they say, is a mensch.More >>

Now here's an intriguing one. A Malaysian politician has issued a thinly veiled threat of mob violence against that country's Chinese minority by warning them not to become like American Jews.

Reports the Associated Press:

Ahmad Ismail, a district chief in the United Malays National Organization ruling party, claimed that the Malay majority was losing patience with minorities, particularly ethnic Chinese politicians.

"I urge the Chinese not to become like the Jewish in America, where it is not enough that they control the economy, but they also want to dominate politics," Ahmad told a news conference late Monday in northern Penang state.

"Consider this a warning from the Malays," Ahmad said. "The patience of the Malays has a limit. Do not push us against the wall, for we will be forced to turn back and push the Chinese for our own survival."

Ahmad is facing an as yet unspecified punishment for these blood-curdling remarks. But this is not the first time that the Chinese minority has been threatened by a leading politician. And it is not the first time that the...More >>

Adam LeBor relates more strange goings-on at the London Review of Books, the publication which ran John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt's original essay on "The Israel Lobby".

According to Adam, the LRB was about to run a review of historian Avi Shlaim's new biography of the late King Hussein of Jordan by Bernard Avishai. At the last moment, apparently, the LRB's editors took exception at Avishai's praising of the King for encouraging the growth of a Palestinian middle class which could play a pivotal role in an independent Palestinian state - not radical enough, you understand. And so the review was pulled and ran in The Nation instead.

Concludes Adam: "The Nation is no great friend of Israel, but at least it has room for dissenting voices." Perhaps, but that, in turn, reminded me of a recent post by Petra Marquardt Bigman about a recent article which revisits a time when The Nation was a great friend of Israel. Says Petra:

"The authors of the piece, Ronald and Allis Radosh, focus on the flagship publication of the American left, The Nation, and highlight how much the magazine's stance towards Israel has changed: nowadays, its...More >>

Canada's Carpenters' Union has just passed a motion at its annual conference condemning boycotts of Israel.

As Ucall Powell, President of the Carpenters' District Council of Ontario says,

Unlike many neighbouring countries, Israel has an active trade union movement that participates freely in Israeli society. Supporting a boycott or sanctions against Israel risks reinforcing terrorist groups and does little to encourage the wellbeing of workers in the region.

Exactly. Read the rest here. A pity not all unions are as sharp as the Canadian carpenters.

 More >>

Ben has already had his say on the Democratiya debate between Martin Shaw and David Hirsh here. I now want to add a couple of thoughts of my own.

1.

Martin Shaw says,

Israel's foundation in 1948, as Israeli historians like Benny Morris and Ilan Pappé have shown, was based on the deliberate, brutal destruction of the larger part of Arab society in Palestine.

I'm not going to get into what level of credibility the work of Pappé and Morris...More >>

Another day, another set of histrionics from Lauren Booth, sister-in-law of Tony Blair and activist with the "Free Gaza" movement - a group which, despite its name, is careful not to make any criticisms of Hamas.

After talking darkly about the dangers posed by the IDF in making the journey to Gaza by boat, the shipmates made it into the Hamas-controlled Strip without so much as a boat search, much less a torpedo. Most of the activists left last week; Booth and a few others stayed on, apparently to do "human rights work." This did not include any declarations of solidarity with those striking Gaza teachers facing a Hamas purge.

Now she's complaining that she can't leave Gaza (check this aptly-entitled post on Fresno Zionism). The Israelis won't let her in via the Erez crossing. The Egyptians won't let her in via the Rafah crossing.

Hold on! The Egyptians? But isn't Gaza totally blockaded by Israel?? No surprises for guessing how Booth gets around this conundrum: the Egyptians aren't letting her through because of Israeli pressure.

As for...More >>

Let me begin with a plug: Democratiya is a superb journal and its latest issue is a veritable bounty of enlightened opinion. Particularly recommended are Michael Walzer's thoughts on how the left can reconstitute its internationalism.

Now to business.

The current issue also carries a debate on antisemitism and the boycott between academics Martin Shaw and David Hirsh. Shaw wrote a short response to Hirsh's piece in the last Democratiya, which rapidly spiralled into a correspondence between the two of them, helpfully reproduced in full. In marked contrast to what passes for debate within the UCU, their exchange is serious and thoughtful. Both are opposed to the boycott. Where they disagree is on the role of antisemitism in all this.

And because they disagree on that, they disagree on so much more than just antisemitism, which leads me to think that their debate is ultimately about competing narratives of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Shaw does not deny that antisemitism is a factor in Middle Eastern politics, but he rejects the idea that it informs the debate on the western left about Israel and...More >>

Hot on the heels of the Jenna Delich affair, yet more leaks from the UCU's activist list have made it into the blogosphere, allowing those of us who are not members to gasp and marvel at the increasingly bizarre state of debate inside the UK's academic union.

Modernity carries a detailed article about the remarks of one Keith Hammond of the University of Glasgow. Here's a taste:

  • Nazi analogies - "The conditions in the Aida camp square with the conditions of the Warsaw ghetto."
  • Israel as an inculcator of evil from cradle to grave - "The whole Israeli education system - from nursery to university - is embedded in the Israeli obsession with war as some sort of ‘defence’ against who knows what … The minute I tried to probe the fears of the Israelis I met the conversation moved into something that I can only describe as a dreadful mix of possibly real and totally unreal anxieties about Europe in the past, Biblical history, contemporary Judaism, work, land and the American dream … These conversations were a gush of insecure and often irrational
  • ...More >>

José Manuel Sánchez Gordillo is a member of the regional parliament of Andalucía for the United Left/Greens/Andalucía's Call party and mayor of the town of Marinaleda. In this story in today's El País, the paper's Jerusalem correspondent Juan Miguel Muñoz describes how, while returning home from Israel after accompanying a number of Palestinian children back to the West Bank after a holiday in Spain, he was "humiliated" by the security...More >>

Pages

Loading...

BUY @ the eSTORE

propagandist tshirt political merchandise buy magazine

Sponsor The Propagandist

Buy The Detective vs. the Slime Monster from Outer Space

political documentaries

Join The Propagandist

Buy A History of The Middle Eastside